Transcript 0:00 The reason you haven't seen consumer applications on blockchain's probably twofold. Within 26 months in market that product, we hit about a billion in annual recurring revenue and penetrated about 72% of the Fortune 500. 0:13 A lot of these global brands are now starting to figure that out. So we're still in a bit of an education phase will tell. 50% of the inbound we get, what you're trying to do does not belong to blockchain. 0:24 A lot of brands were experimenting, but perhaps not really sure on what their strategy should be. And we keep hammering away at this. You know, I think what Abstract hopefully becomes is this digital Disneyland of fun. 0:35 Video games are probably the one of the few categories within entertainment that you know your entire user base, right? 0:41 You know, when you have these conversations with CEOs, they care about three things and three things only. Hello, everyone. Welcome to The Speakeasy. 0:51 This is a series that will interview innovators from across sports, entertainment, gaming, and technology. Uh, I'm Joe Condon. This is my co-host, Jay Stewart. 1:00 And today we're joined by Michael Ly, co-founder and CEO of Abstract. Thank you for joining us, Michael. Hey, hey. What's good? All good. All good. 1:08 So Michael, tell us a, a, a bit about yourself before we get into talking about Abstract and about your own background. 1:14 Um, you know, like as Joe mentioned, co-founder, uh, CEO of Abstract, uh, which is a consumer-focused blockchain platform, um, aimed at onboarding the next billion people, uh, into, into the cryptoverse. 1:30 And then before that, head various stints across Wall Street, gaming, uh, TV, hip-hop, uh, just- Through. [laughs] Yeah. 1:42 To be honest, it's just generally just what, you know, I think at any moment in time, like, whatever just, you know, kind of like blows your hair back. Mm-hmm. 1:50 But the gaming world that the, the, the gaming, the time you spent in gaming really probably informed your view of where, where things were going next. 1:58 To be honest, like it's, it actually all starts just growing up in New York in like the early '90s, and I think with that... 'Cause 2:06 I was super fortunate to where one of my best friends growing up was Rick Rubin's nephew. 2:12 So, you know, we were able to, you know, go to like Brooklyn and see like Biggie, and go to Queens to see Nas and Wu-Tang in Staten Island. 2:21 And, you know, again, like, you know, it was like that token like Jewish and Asian kid that was given safe passage to- [laughs]... 2:28 to go, you know, go to see these shows and, and you're just, you know, to be able to be in the culture and, you know, start to appreciate it, and later on, like contribute to the culture. 2:37 Like, I think that's where a lot of that started, and then obviously just being this like hood rat just skating around, you know, New York City. Like, again, like skate culture turned into streetwear. 2:49 Uh, at least, you know, again, like streetwear was around, you know, and vibrant with like, with Stussy and, you know, uh, Supreme, like from like the '70s and the '80s. 2:59 But again, like there was like, uh, that renaissance of streetwear that, you know, eventually like kind of Virgil brought to the mainstream with Off-White. 3:06 And a lot of that, you know, these kids that, you know, we kind of grew up together, you know, started skateboarding and then that kinda turned into, you know, some of them moved to the music, sports, entertainment, and fashion. 3:18 And again, from there it's like, you know, you know, you are a kind of a culmination of the institutions you grew up in. 3:24 So I think just a lot of the things that I did was always kind of based on that, just kind of growing up in the culture and then trying to contribute to, you know, shaping and moving culture. Mm. 3:34 So, you know, weirdly enough, kinda started off on Wall Street, and then that turned into, from that to, you know, going into Comedy Central and TV where I was like doing, I was like the token hip hop sketch comedy, uh, showrunner. 3:50 And then, you know, it just kind of evolves to where I think y- I think the gaming, the gaming bit started off with, um, I was writing these like shitty sketches that, you know- [laughs]... nobody really cared for. 4:01 And I just, you know, this is like, what? Between like '04 to '08, um, when Modern Warfare came out, I think it was like in '06, '07, um, just nights and weekends just got ridiculously good at it. 4:14 Became one of the top players. 4:16 And this is, again, this is before esports and, uh, you know, it was just you're playing with friends and family and just, you know, the, you know, the massive community that, you know, Call of Duty became. 4:26 And just got into like the space, and it wasn't something that I did full-time. It was just kind of, you know, something I enjoyed. 4:34 But then again, you get to know a lot of the folks at Activision Blizzard, and then just years later, um, 4:40 a friend of mine that was on the board, you know, was saying that, "Hey, CEO, the team are really focused on, you know, this, uh, merger with Microsoft and, but there's five games coming out in a period of 18 months and, you know, can you kind of come in and help, help launch some games?" 4:56 Which again, you know, it's not something that I had expertise in, but you know, you kind of figure it out. You, you don't say no to that. [laughs] No, I, you know, to be honest, I generally say yes to everything. Yeah. 5:07 And like my entire like career has been just improv, where- But, but, but you're, in other words, your, your background is not really tech. I mean, you're, now you're, the, the space you're in is very much about, 5:17 about technology and about culture and technology, but you, you, you came from culture into tech rather than the other way around. Yeah. Um, to be honest, like just I'm an economist by trade. 5:28 Uh, and, you know, went to, you know, everything from undergrad to the doctoral program, which I never finished, uh, for economics. And it's, you know, I think a lot of the things that I do, whether it's, um, 5:44 you're writing television to launching games, to building technology, I think the lens that I always look at it through is through economics, which essentially, you know, is the study of human behavior through incentives. 5:58 And, you know, especially now in the crypto space- So much of that is, like, this, this kind of intersection of not only tech, but finance and culture. 6:09 And I think within there, you're, you s- at least in the last probably, what, ten years since Ethereum had launched, what, July of twenty fifteen, it's been this grand experiment of, you know, how do you align, uh, incentives to where all three of these things are at play? 6:26 And hopefully, you know, it creates, you know... I think what a, I think what's emerging now is just, like, this culture economy for Gen Z and Gen Alpha. 6:35 And maybe that's a good segue into what you guys are doing with Abstract now, which is kind of blending technology with culture. Um- Yeah. I think a lot of it, it, it starts, um... 6:47 I was in the Ethereum seed round, uh, back in like twenty fifteen, and I'd worked on, on Ethereum, like as most people do. 6:55 Um, you know, you work on Ethereum just like on nights and weekends, um, at the, on-- It was called Eth2.0 back then. Grinding. [laughs] Uh, yeah, just, you know. 7:05 That was like way back when, when, you know, that was the only way to make Ethereum go fast. And a lot of us came from, from consumer. Um, how, you know, I was at Comedy Central. 7:16 You know, I was also in the political marketplace, as well as like working at a lot of like big brands, and it's like, how do I bring a lot of that, you know, to this emerging space called crypto and Web3? 7:28 And there's people from, you know, Fortune Five Hundred companies, you know, just go-to brands and IP, and I think we all had this vision of consumer crypto. 7:39 And when you look at, uh, just consumer in general, there's always these shifts, and I always look at the shifts, uh, by computing paradigm shifts. Every eight to twelve years is a shift, right? 7:50 Um, before my time, but it was, you know, you started with mainframes to client server and then to cloud, and then you went to mobile and then containers, which this is like back in, what, uh, twenty fourteen. 8:03 I'd, uh, taken technology out of Google called Kubernetes, and we commercialized it. And with each of these, there's always an explosion of apps, consumer apps. 8:14 Like trillions of dollars, you know, like is, of value is generated. 8:18 So like a good example is, you know, with the transition to the cloud, you had two dominant things, uh, that came up, which was, you know, e-commerce led by Amazon and social media with Facebook. 8:29 And then once you, we moved over to, to, to mobile as a computing paradigm, there's three things that were unique about mobile is one is the portability, right? 8:39 Um, you just now have this super computer in your pocket, and that, at least for me, like coming up through gaming, it opened up mobile gaming as a category, right? 8:49 Where now that's the dominant, uh, uh, you know, kind of sub-vertical within the gaming industry. 8:56 'Cause now all of a sudden, like, you know, people can slice some fruit, crush some candy, play Clash, like, you know, in their kind of commute from point A to B. 9:04 Um, GPS, you know, that allowed for, you know, Uber, right? 9:09 You know, before, before the mobile phone, it's not like you're not walking around New York City with a laptop trying to catch a, you know, trying to catch a cab. And then ultimately, um, the camera. 9:20 That allowed for the evolution of social, where, you know, you have Instagram where you're instantly capturing the moment. 9:25 And then when we shifted over to, uh, containers, you had, you know, kind of two kind of emerging technologies in Docker and Kubernetes. 9:35 And when I saw that, um, 'cause again, coming out of, you know, being in and, in and out of gaming, I saw that transition from just in TV to Twitch. 9:45 And when Kubernetes as a technology came out, um, there was this, this, you know, what people used it for was nerd, you know, the kind of the nerdy tech term was, uh, microservices architecture. 9:56 Essentially, it's, you know, it's making software like, you know, as fast as like startups in Silicon Valley do. 10:02 And when I saw that, uh, all of us, uh, that were working on it, you automatically saw that it could, it could optimize streaming. And streaming was already... It, it existed, but it, it wasn't at the scale it is now. 10:16 And when we commercialized it, I think the first clients, uh, we had were Netflix, Discord, and, uh, Twitch. 10:26 And then, you know, as the cool kids are using any technology, you have, you know, I think by within twenty-six months in market, that product, we hit about a billion in annual recurring revenue and penetrated about seventy-two percent of the Fortune Five Hundred. 10:39 Crazy. So I think that's kind of-- And again, like that was just product market fit. You know, right place, right time. And but then again, when we took that, you know, that was from like twenty fourteen. 10:52 IPO'd in twenty eighteen. So again, like it's been a minute, right? It's like that eight to twelve years, so it's, you know, if containers was like that last shift, you know, we're kind of due up for the next thing. 11:04 And a lot of us kinda coming into, you know, crypto and, and Ethereum, you know, we were just early. 11:11 Like a lot of this stuff takes about, you know, ten years to get to the point where that the underlying technology is, you know, pretty hard and stable to where people can then start building, you know, consumer experiences on top. 11:25 And again, like that's what Abstract is. Like, you know, it's-- We were probably at that, what, Ethereum launching in twenty fifteen. Like, you know, we were at that moment where when we started Abstract March of '24. 11:39 It was myself, uh, Luca, Lorenzo from, uh, the Pudgy Penguin team. 11:45 And again, these are absolutely go-to guys that came from Web2, you know, bought this, you know, kind of Web3 native IP, uh, and then just turned Pudgy Penguins into kind of the crypto version of Mickey Mouse to where- You know, it's now kind of like the de facto face of, of crypto, especially for, for normies, um, and global brands where you now see pudgy penguins in Walmarts and Targets and is ringing the bell at the New York Stock Exchange. 12:17 And so they were coming at consumer crypto from like a, a different, a different lens. 12:23 Um, but again, like we, we kind of all saw the same opportunity to where we just figured the reason you haven't seen consumer, consumer applications on blockchains is probably twofold. 12:35 One, like the infrastructure wasn't ready for prime time. 12:39 And then two, what people don't understand about consumer is that you can't just, you know, create this, you know, computing paradigm, a general purpose compute- computing platform and say, you know, "Go have at it." 12:50 It's generally not how it works. In order to do consumer, you have to do three things. Curation. It's like, you know, as, 12:59 as my kids come onto the internet, they're not going to a webpage and clicking on a bunch of links. They're coming to, you know, Amazon for products. They're coming to Netflix for content, right? 13:09 They're coming to, you know, the App Store or the Play Store for apps. 13:14 Um, and once you figure that out of curation, 'cause no one wants to go dumpster diving for apps and experiences, then all of a sudden you gotta do discoverability, right? 13:24 So like when I was coming up on, you know, mobile with the, the App Store, you know, I'm playing Clash, I get served other games. I'm not getting served a workplace productivity tool, and vice versa, right? 13:35 You know, as you download Slack, you know, you're not getting served, you know, you know, Candy Crush. Um, and once you've done that, you know, curation, discoverability, then it's distribution. 13:47 But then again, like nobody in, in the crypto space has really put that all together. And in building Abstract, again, it's, it's a blockchain, but that part is an absolute commodity. 13:59 There's like five hundred blockchains out there. Um, they're fairly undifferentiated. 14:04 The thing that we've built is this consumer Bloomberg terminal on top that feels hopefully like, you know, a Sony PlayStation wallet meets the Apple App Store meets Twitch, kind of all in one vertical. 14:17 Maybe we could touch on that because it is pretty unique from, in a Web3 space where people go, and they can have access to everything. And some of the numbers that we were chatting about just off- Mm... 14:29 offset were- Yeah... amazing. No, and again, still early days. Uh, we launched the platform, I think literally a hundred and thirty-three days ago. And in that time, 14:41 I think we've hit two point six million accounts created. Um, the, probably the, the metric that I look at is not just user acquisition, but user retention. 14:52 So coming from gaming, you know, you're always tracking like day one, seven, day thirty, especially, uh, user retention. And, uh, we're at about fifty-nine percent user retention. So, you know- Wow... 15:04 from, you know, the folks coming in day one, you know, fifty-nine percent of them are, you know, still, you know, monthly active users, uh, by day thirty. And just for context, 15:15 I think Amazon's-- Again, these are world-class applications, uh, and companies. Amazon's probably at, what, seven to eight percent, um, thirty-day retention. 15:28 Uh, Netflix, Disney Plus, they're probably somewhere between nine and thirteen percent. Um, coming from Call of Duty, uh, which definitely outperforms the benchmark. 15:39 The benchmark for AAA games is about five to ten percent at the thirty-day mark, and Call of Duty is probably hovering somewhere around like twenty-five percent. Mm. 15:48 So again, still early days, but you know, just blowing, you know, the lid off of a lot of these metrics. So why is that? What are, what is the, the, the thing that makes that the, the case? 15:59 I think, one, we're hyper targeting, uh, Gen Z and Gen Alpha, um, uh, these users with discretionary income, but from eight to twelve high GDP markets. 16:11 So it's, you know, it's North America, it's Western Europe, it's, you know, uh, kind of North Asia, you know, in China, Korea, Japan. And I think these are just, you know... 16:22 It kind of tracks with, you know, the Apple iOS market. 16:25 And I think these are consumers that are just, you know, that are used to, you know, apps and, uh, you know, that whole freemium model, but also kind of paying for, you know, unlocking more content. 16:39 And again, like you're just, you're using the underlying computing environment, which is blockchain, to provide, you know, net new types of experiences, which again, like, you know, s- seems like, you know, two point six million, 16:52 uh, you know, users are super excited about what's possible. And it, it, it hopefully it feels like you're opening up a new section of the internet. I think that's what gets people excited. 17:02 Well, one of the things we have to touch on, Michael, is the consumer experience in terms of the technology that they're, they're using. And, and I think it's important, um, maybe hear from you as to 17:14 their experience in terms of Web2, Web3, what it is. They don't really need to know what the, the underlying technology is- Yeah... do they? No, and this is why we called it Abstract. 17:25 We- we're literally abstracting away the technology. Um, you know, people don't care. Like, again, like when, you know, we're, you know, on a Zoom, 17:34 like you have no idea that it, whether it's running on AWS, Google Cloud, uh, Microsoft Azure, you know, there's probably containers involved, whether it's Kubernetes or it's Docker. 17:46 You know, you generally don't give a shit. Um, you just care that it works. You care that it's connecting, you know, you to that, you know, those other people. Um, and you can say that about any app, right? 17:57 Um, you know, even like in, you know, like in Instagram, it's like, again, you have no idea like what that tech stack is, nor do you care. 18:04 Um- I think that's the, I think that's, I think that's the thing that I think we're seeing that transition happen. Hopefully, you know, with Abstract in the lead where, 18:14 you know, I think in these, in these early days of Web3 crypto, it was, it was very technology first, as it should be. Um, and you saw that with the rise of mobile gaming, too. Um, very much about, you know, 18:29 the new technology that enabled, you know, building games fundamentally differently. And it's the same thing with crypto. 18:35 It's, you know, the last ten years has really been about like, you know, trying to figure out, you know, new technologies, how to optimize some of the things that, you know, are working. 18:45 Um, but I think the shift has now happened to where people are now focusing, you know, at the app layer and trying to figure out like, okay, how do I excite? How do I build, one, a sustainable business? 18:56 And then how do I, you know, in order to do that, how do I actually provide value to, to my end users and my customers? 19:03 And I, and I think you saw this recently with, um, you know, working with, uh, you know, Oracle Red Bull Racing. Again, 19:11 shit smart group of people in experimenting with emerging technologies like Abstract to where, you know, at the Monaco race weekend, you know, when they launched a, you know, digital collectible series, which, you know, at face value just kind of, you know, it feels like, you know, it feels like digital like Pokemon cards. 19:31 Um, but what it really represented was, you know, a kind of a really interesting like, you know, fan engagement tool as well as, uh, you know, a user acquisition tool of, you know, of Gen A and Gen Z. 19:45 And again, like, you know, with close to about a million, you know, uh, digital collectibles claimed, I guarantee ninety-five percent of them have no idea that, that that's, that's on enabled by crypto rails. 20:00 Um, nor should they care, right? They just, they should just care that, you know, they're able to be closer to the brand, right? 20:07 They're, you know, hopefully, you know, there's better fan engagement, better opportunities for them to interact with the brand. 20:14 Um, and as well as like, you know, join the community of other kind of FOne and, uh, Oracle Red Bull Racing enthusiasts. And these are all things that I think, you know, provide value, provide fun. 20:26 Um, and the moment that you force technology down someone's throat and really make it front and center, um, yeah, that's when it just stops being fun. 20:37 I think we, we saw, especially over the last few years, that a lot of brands were experimenting, but perhaps not really sure on what their strategy should be. 20:46 I guess obviously the collectibles is step one of a bigger kind of vision of how it ties into them improving fan engagement or engage with their fans or attracting new audiences to the brand. 20:57 So I wondered whether we could kind of look at what the bigger picture is of that step one, but what's step ten, let's say, for Red Bull doing that? Yeah. 21:05 And it-- and this is, this isn't necessarily specific to, you know, Web3, Abstract. Uh, 21:15 I think, you know, kind of seeing all these shifts in computing, you know, any kind of emerging technology in that given moment, whether it's the cloud, mobile, containers, and now blockchain. Uh, 21:26 you know, when you have these conversations with CEOs that they care about three things and three things only. It's how do I make more money? How do I save money? Or how do I better engage my customers, fans, partners? 21:40 And which kind of comes back to how do I make more money? 'Cause again, they're businesses, right? 21:45 And in order to be a sustainable business, you have to, you know, generate revenue, so then you can obviously continue, continue doing the good work. 21:55 Um, and the moment that you, I think you frame any conversation that way, the technology is, is, is less important. 22:04 It's more, okay, what are you-- what business outcome are you trying to achieve, you know, in service of the one of these three things that is life or death for your company? Um, and I think in the case of, you know, 22:17 I think it's not necessarily just, just Red Bull Racing. It's actually probably all of the, the global brands that, that we're currently working with. 22:24 Uh, most of them in stealth, but, uh, they'll come over-- they'll, they'll launch, you know, throughout the course of this year. All of them are really focused for us, uh, in working with Abstract is 22:35 how do I better engage a younger audience? Again, 'cause, you know, what we've kind of quickly become, uh, using crypto rails has become a, a publisher. 22:44 You know, very similar to Activision Blizzard, uh, with their, you know, six hundred and fifty million, uh, users. 22:51 And, you know, with us having, you know, two point six million in these early days and, you know, with that retention rate that we have, you know, we'll s- we'll get to, you know, fifty, a hundred million, you know, in, in due time. 23:05 But we're essentially this user acquisition engine for Gen A and Gen Z. So as we work with brands, like they're looking at us, um, one, use the technology, build something really interesting that engages their core base. 23:19 Um, but then also how do they introduce what they're doing, what their brand is about to our audience or some subsection of our audience? And this is kinda where you saw this where- Yeah... 23:31 I think where, you know, they probably brought on about two hundred and fifty thousand, uh, you know, kind of Oracle Red Bull Racing fans, um, you know, into the Abstract universe. 23:42 And now you're kind of doing the discoverability to, you know, introduce them to other apps. But we also sent them probably a little over six hundred thousand eyeballs. 23:51 Um, again, you know, out of the two point six million, you know, you gotta imagine that a good number of them are, you know, FOne enthusiasts. Mm-hmm. 23:59 So they're aware of FOne, and we've just kind of pointed them towards Red Bull's direction, and hopefully they've, you know, they've become a, a Red Bull racing fan. 24:08 So in terms of the actual product that when you have a collectible that's, that's created and that excites people and people wanna be part of 24:15 How does that process work, and wh- wh- how do you work with your partners in identifying those and then, and then enrolling them out? 24:24 I th- I think the credit always goes to whether it's, you know, there's two cohorts of, uh, um, kind of builders that we work with. I think there's the crypto-native startups, and there's... 24:34 You know, that'll always kind of, you know, by 10 to one, uh, like as a ratio, like, s- you know, uh, always be kind of have primacy on any new platform. And then you have these global brands. 24:49 Um, they're both very similar. Um, I think what... where you'll find the crypto-native startups or any startup, um, they're looking for unique properties of that platform, right? 25:00 Going back to the example of like mobile, like the most successful apps, mobile apps were the ones that took advantage of one of those three things, you know, the mobility element, um, GPS or the camera. 25:13 And I think you'll, you're starting to see, you know, crypto-native startups look for things that are unique to blockchain that other computing paradigms don't have. Um, so then it, it becomes a net... 25:25 a unique app that is truly like, you know, belongs on crypto rails versus something that's, you know, that's like a Web2 app that's LARPing as- Mm-hmm... as, uh, Web3. 25:35 And then global brands, um, the most successful ones are, again, you go back to those three things that your business desperately needs, but then you have to overlay them because they're so general. 25:46 Like, 'cause, like, of course, everyone wants to make more revenue. 25:49 But I think you kinda have to go to what, what is unique about your business that, you know, for this year, um, is going to generate more revenue, right? 26:00 I think for, in the case of, uh, F1 and, you know, Oracle Red Bull Racing, it's, you know, it was, it was very much getting, you know, to a younger demo, um, and better engaging them. 26:12 So then again, you know, I would imagine that, you know, this audience, you know, that cohort has, you know, probably better, like, you know, LTV. Uh, 26:21 so you kinda wanna get them early, especially now, you know, with, with F1. G- again, like, uh, I grew up on, on the circuit and again, like, even like during the Schumacher days, like F1 wasn't what it is now. Mm. 26:34 Right? It's-- this is, you know, it's kind of elevated like, you know, 100X. 26:39 And I think, you know, all the teams on the grid are taking advantage of that moment, especially Red Bull, and trying to figure out, "All right. 26:47 How do we, you know, now that we have this younger generation's interest, you know, how do we, you know, re- truly get them, you know, locked in as a, a racing fan as well as, you know, uh, a fan of my particular team versus, you know, any- anyone else on the grid?" 27:01 Hmm. So I think, again, it, it always just comes back to with each of these brands, like there's something that's unique about what they're trying to achieve, you know, this, in this calendar year. 27:11 And s- it doesn't always require the blockchain. So a lot of times we'll tell 50% of the inbound we get, it's like, "We can't help you." Like, "What you're trying to do does not belong on the blockchain." 27:25 But in general, you always wanna do something, one, bring that technology with something like Abstract into your core tech stack, 27:35 and try to figure out how do you, how do you leverage that technology to, to kind of accelerate something that you've already been trying to do versus something net new, right? So this is 27:45 again, going back to containers and why Kubernetes, commercial Kubernetes was so successful is, you know, I think the, 27:54 I think the lu- I think the thing, the impulsive thing would be always, "Let me go create something new." Hmm. Something greenfield. 28:00 Um, and you saw that with, with crypto probably the last two cycles, where everyone wanted to use the blockchain to do something net new 'cause, like, you know, that's probably what's exciting and, you know, like, uh, internally gets, you know, probably, maybe a lot of, you know, uh, kind of political momentum. 28:20 But the thing that always does well is like how do you use new technologies to kind of do something that you've been trying to do, uh, just get that out and then or just optimization, and then you can do the greenfield stuff. 28:32 So a good example for Kubernetes was that we started off, uh, refactoring everyone's website, and s- super boring. 28:42 Um, but a lot of the, especially as corporates, you know, big brands were using Kubernetes, you know, they, they, they wanted to jump right to, "I wanna use this platform to build software as quickly as Silicon Valley does." 28:52 It was like, "All right, like that's a, that's, that's great aspiration, but that's probably not the first thing that you should start off with." Mm-hmm. 28:59 'Cause, you know, I think when we were-- s- good examples, you know, so something like Comcast. We're chatting with them and, and it started off as, you know, well, one, "What the fuck is containers?" 29:12 And I was like, it's, you know, it's, I think the, the thing that most people would do is talk about the technology. But what we, what we had sold was time to market, speed to market. 29:25 And they're like, "What does that mean in the context of, you know, say like a Comcast?" And you look at their website or any, you know, Fortune 500 company's website, it was built, you know, in this monolithic fashion. 29:35 So if you wanted to change the Contact Us button from, you know, red to green, probably take you like seven to nine months, right? Hmm. 29:43 Compared to like Amazon, where that website, even though they look the same, um, it's built differently. 29:50 It's-- the Amazon website is built in a microservices architecture where it's like a mosaic of 10,000 little puzzle pieces. So come Christmas time, you know, I wanna drop a little Santa hat on the shopping cart. 30:01 As long as I have that asset, uh, y- you deploy it in about seven seconds, right? 30:06 So th- there's a fundamental difference when you, you're getting your lunch eaten by Silicon Valley startups because they're just able to get, get to market much faster. They're able to iterate, uh, much faster. 30:18 We get customer feedback and continue to like improve that product, where you're just struggling with, you know, making this- Simple change, but again, because there's so many pages to your website, it's translated in just 'cause you operate in maybe like 155 countries, like, you know, that simple thing takes seven, nine months. 30:37 So again, we kind of refactor everyone's website to where it, it's built, you know, in a very nimble way. 30:44 And then once you do that, then you have to, you kind of also kind of stop that impulse of, "All right, let's jump to the net new thing." And then you go to, 30:53 "Let me refactor your, kind of your core applications that run your company." So someone like Netflix has 40,000 applications that runs that empire, right? Whereas a lot of these Fortune 500 companies had like 50. 31:09 So if your kind of one finance app application goes down, it's like you can't, you can't, you know, collect or send money out. Um, 31:20 whereas, you know, like in the case of like a, a Netflix or any of these like Silicon Valley shops, you know, just, you know, an outage of one of 5,000 finan-finance apps, like, you know, your business still runs. 31:33 And so it was very much like rebuilding a lot of those internal systems, which it's just boring, but it's, you know, it's, it's vital if you wanted to like, hopefully, you know, uh, get to market much faster and be competitive. 31:46 And then by year three, you've gotten great at building software, your internal team, to where now you can actually do greenfield stuff, right? 31:53 Things like get into streaming, and that's where you kind of see Peacock coming, uh, from a large, you know, a large enterprise. 32:02 Uh, I guess it comes back to that positioning, especially when you, you talked about kind of pitching it to C-level. So, you know, they're not interested necessarily in the nuts and bolts of what the technology is. 32:12 They're, they're, they're bothered about what it enables and what it, they can do better. Yeah. 32:17 Um, what, I guess coming back to, you know, your experiences now with global brands, what are you finding is kind of the key aspects that they're kind of using Web3 for? 32:27 Like, where are they finding value or the most kind of impact within the business? User, customer, fan engagement. 32:39 And that kind of goes, you know, it's probably a couple different ways depending on what industry you're in. 32:46 Um, you're seeing a lot of, there's a lot of conversations now in building prototyping around how do you take something like a loyalty program, leverage 32:57 blockchain, Abstract to fundamentally just, I don't know, breathe new life into it, right? Like, the ideal loyalty and rewards program just it makes sense, right? 33:09 But the way that people do it now, it's j- it just feels just s- super flat. Um- You get sent a scarf once a year. [laughs] Yeah. 33:16 And it's, it, there really isn't this like, you know, kind of this, you're not using that as a weapon to build this emotional connection with your, um, with your customer base. 33:27 And I think this is what I think crypto has done really, really well where... And there's a couple of industries, whether it's like, you know, it's Web3, it's, it's gaming, K-pop, uh, you know. 33:40 And a lot of this is also, you know, the military, I think, you know, religion does as well, right? Where there's this, you know, there's this community. Mm. Right? 33:49 Shared beliefs, you know, shared incentive systems, and there's just this, you know, fervor, um, that also continues to, you know, kind of draw more people into that community. Yeah. 34:01 And I think crypto has done that really, really well. And again, if you look at crypto, uh, it's, it's, you know, these r- really like a, you know, uh, elegant like, uh, incentive systems. 34:15 And I think a lot of these global brands are now starting to figure that out to where that's probably one of the superpowers of blockchain, where, you know, we could, you know, use this technology to figure out how do we supercharge what we're currently doing with loyalty and rewards. 34:30 And again, I think this is why Abstract, you know, Abstract has built that into it as itself- Mm... 34:35 right, with our, with our kind of like, you know, triple A gaming inspired XP system with badges which also feels like, you know, getting badges in Call of Duty. 34:44 Um, and I think when you, if you can do that right, again, now you've, you've gamified it in a very, I think, in an exciting way where, you know, it creates, you know, excitement for that particular customer, that user. 34:59 It creates, you know, kind of incentivizes community depending on how you're, you're building that. Um, it, it also gives people a sense of, you know, uh, status- Mm... 35:10 and progression like within that community, um, 'cause people are now ranking up, and they're, you know, there's different tiers. 35:17 Um, again, like it also now turns it into like a social platform to set- 'cause again, like, you know, I, I grew up playing Call of Duty and World of Warcraft. 35:26 World of Warcraft, when that came out, I don't think people really understood, uh, again, like, you know, having been at Activision Blizzard, like the folks who are probably what, top 10%, they play like 42 hours a week. 35:38 Mm. And they're also consuming 24 hours of game related content. [laughs] And then it seems like mind-blowing numbers, but when you think about it, you know, that player base is using... 35:50 It's not just a game for them, right? It is, it's a game, but it's also entertainment. Mm. It is a social platform. It is a t- it is a number of different things kind of, you know, kind of all r- bundle into one thing. 36:03 And so then if you actually think about like any kind of, you know, whether it's myself or any of us, it's like you kind of count up, you know, you know, how many hours a week do you, you know, are you just doom scrolling on TikTok and- Yeah... 36:15 you know, wa- crushing through Netflix and, uh, all these things. And it probably, you know, averages out to about the same amount of time people, you know, players spend on, uh, on Warcraft. 36:27 So I think if you do that right, um, you know, using crypto rails- I think a lot of these brands can absolutely, um, supercharge loyalty and reward systems, um, and programs. 36:39 There's-- I think there's this element of digital collectibles where, I think where, I think 36:45 Oracle Red Bull Racing has done a good job where there's like a, a raffle element to it, to where, you know, how do you use digital collectibles to kind of also pass on the ability to win, you know, whether it's, you know, swag to driver signed merch, to race used memorabilia, to the g- the grand prize for this, you know, two thousand and five, uh, season is, you know, uh, tickets to a grand prix of your choice. 37:13 And 37:14 I think they're doing a great job of, you know, I think, you know, you know, it's using digital collectibles and adding like an additional element to further engage fans, which again, like digital collectibles have been around for forever, right? 37:26 I think Pokemon's crushing it right now with it. But they're adding this like twist to it, um, you know, like this raffle twist, um, that lets connects, you know, uh, fans with, um, you know, you know, different rewards. 37:41 How about the idea, I mean, we have... You, you have communities. You're building a community. 37:44 You said you have to two point six million or two point eight million, uh, people in your, um, on, on your platform, or let's say is in your publishing c- uh, community. In- How about the interaction with others? 37:59 I mean, is it a question of dipping in and then out to go somewhere else? How do you... How does your world or your group, how does it connect with everyone else? 38:11 So once you come in, and you'll generally come in with this like an anchor app, right? 38:16 Whether it's, you know, uh, what Oracle Red Bull Racing is doing, or maybe there's like a crypto native startup, uh, like a game or prediction market that you'll come in. 38:26 And then once you're in, you know, again, I think the... And this credit to the kind of the core product engineering team, um, the way that you kinda come into Abstract is through mostly social login, right? 38:40 With, with email, uh, Google account, um, passkey, which is touch ID, face ID. 38:47 Um, you know, obviously there's also, you know, for the crypto natives, you can log in with an existing, uh, kinda crypto wallet, like a MetaMask. 38:55 But the vast majority, probably close to eighty percent come in through, you know, the social login, uh, uh, methods. And probably within three seconds, um, people have a Abstract global wallet. 39:10 Um, kinda feels like a Sony PlayStation wallet. Mm. And then you're just-- you are now like in this app store, um, highly curated. 39:19 And it just, you know, within there you'll s- you know, you'll kind of discover these apps that ex- hopefully, you know, excite you, and you'll f- you'll find those communities, uh, within there, whether it's kind of following, following them on socials or Discord or wherever that community gathers and, you know, uh, has conversation, shares tips. 39:38 Um, and then w- within the platform itself of Abstract, there's also streaming. So hope it, you know, you're now kind of... It's almost as if, you know, Activision Blizzard had Twitch kind of really built in. 39:50 Um, or, you know, uh, maybe S-Steam is a better example. 39:54 You're kinda coming into Steam, you see this universe of games, and there's also, you know, Twitch is like, you know, kind of, you know, or, you know, it's organically part of it. 40:02 And within there, you'll start seeing different creators that are, you know, streaming games, your favorite games, prediction markets, and, you know, creator platforms. 40:12 And there's, you know, people are, you know, having conversations there as well, you know, in the chat. And they're also sending tips, uh, to the creator, um, peer to peer tipping. 40:23 And so there's like different, different ways whether it's, you know, people kind of spin off into, you know, app specific, uh, channels where that community gathers. 40:32 Or they'll kind of all kind of gather around, you know, around different streams, uh, on that particular app of their choice. But it's, it's kind of around discovery again. Like someone- Yeah... 40:43 has one entry point, but then they're kind of met with numerous different options. 40:48 And I think that's, that's quite interesting, like obviously we're covering sports, entertainment, games, technology, all of which make up part of someone's identity or they've got numerous different interests. 40:59 Um, so it's, it's, I guess it's down to how do you kinda service those interests in kind of a three sixty way? Because there's numerous ways that people could enter. Yeah. There's, 41:10 you know, Abstract is effectively a three-sided marketplace where it's user, builder, and creator. 41:17 And so we, we focus first on, you know, like a publisher, like an Activision Blizzard, your, your user acquisition engine, right? 41:25 So we are targeting, you know, Gen Z, Gen Alpha, you know, with discretionary income from eight to twelve high GDP markets. 41:34 Like, as long as we do that first and well, you're gonna get the best apps, whether they're, you know, kind of native to the plat- crypto native startups, or you're gonna get, you know, uh, global brands, um, you know, across sports, entertainment, um, you know, notable IP and consumer brands. 41:52 'Cause again, they're, they're also, you know, what, what startups want desperately more than some kind of like grant or a handout is users, right? 'Cause they wanna be a sustainable business. 42:02 You know, what, you know, global brands want, you know, is again, access to a younger, you know, audience that hopefully become, you know, part of what they're building. 42:13 And so you'll automatically get the best builders, the best brands if you have a great user base. Um, 42:21 and we, we predominantly focus on these eight to twelve markets that have high GDP 'cause again, you know, consumer requires discretionary spending power. 42:31 Um, and eventually we'll get to other regions, you know, whether it's Southeast Asia, India, Africa, Latin America, but, you know, we're kind of- Focus on these eight to 12 markets, uh, that we think are important for us, and then we'll eventually try to figure out, you know, what is helpful for other, other geos. 42:50 And then I think the last part is creators. Uh, mostly streamers for us. Uh, you know, I think whenever there's new platforms, everyone over-indexes on builders. Um, and but what builders really want is users. Mm-hmm. 43:04 And what also users and builders also want are stre- and you saw this in, you know, the rise of the meteoric rise, uh, recently in probably like the last 10 years in gaming. 43:15 So much of that is, you know, you know, publishing and, you know, promoting. It's right now it's on the backs of creators. Like anyth- you know, any, any Web2 like social platform, right? 43:26 Whether it's Facebook to Instagram to TikTok, like that's all user-generated content, right? You know, the rise of all these games, uh, you know, it is all on the backs of streamers on Twitch. 43:39 And, and I think, I think what we've, uh, figured out was, you know, as these apps start to, you know, go from zero to one, like, you know, in trying to get, you know, your kind of your in- your core user base. 43:53 Like Abstract could help them like instantly. Like if you've built something really compelling, you could probably trip over 25,000 to 50,000 DAUs. 44:04 Now it's up to you to hopefully get to from one to 100, which is trying to find out, okay, you know, how do I scale this thing a little bit further to where I'm building a sustainable business? 44:13 But in order to get to that 100 to 1,000, where you're really getting into hypergrowth, like you need more than, you know, me and, you know, the core team tweeting out and promoting you. 44:25 You need your kind of, you know, your own kind of group of creators that are promoting, you know, I think not only what you're building, but again, like that entire, you know, kind of the sub ecosystem that you've- Mm... 44:37 you built this sub community. And if you look at streaming, it's, you know, hopefully for entrepreneurs and brands, it looks like a marketplace of, you know, people that can help promote what you're doing. 44:51 Um, for users is it's, it's content, and I think this is why we have such a high, a 59%, uh, retention rate on the 30-day mark. It's 45:02 when you're coming into this ecosystem, into Abstract, you know, there's a highly curated marketplace of apps. 45:09 So hopefully there's, you know, we're able to, you know, bring you in and have you on an anchor app with, you know, within, you know, a few clicks. 45:17 'Cause if you're dumpster diving for apps, like you're gonna spin out, right? There has to be like about a one in three, one in five chance that you're gonna find an, an anchor app where we can then do discoverability. 45:28 But then again, most people, and I think it's, it's, it's not, this is not rocket science, all right? Um, but most people, if you go that strategy, it becomes a hit-driven business, right? 45:40 That people are only gonna continue to come back into that kind of Bloomberg consumer terminal, um, you know, for the next, you know, app of the week. 45:49 And again, like, uh, this stuff is pretty, you know, mercurial where it's like, you know, there's some weeks where there's like three banger apps that come out, and there's like a stretch of two weeks where 45:59 there really isn't anything interesting. And I think what retains people is, is the streaming to where- Mm... 46:05 you know, it's, I think we found ourselves to where even in the 133 days, the w- the niche that we find, uh, we find people using Abstract is during breaks. Breaks during school, breaks during work. 46:18 Like 15, 20-minute breaks. Like you have a break. We're not competing with like, you know, primetime television, you know, where you're watching like the NBA finals. 46:29 You're not, we're not, you know, competing with, you know, AAA games. We're competing for that so much of mobile games, right? Mobile games we're competing against like reading a book on the subway, right? 46:41 Uh, in that kind of commute from, you know, A to B. Mm. We're competing for that dead time, uh, where you're just, you know- Mm... you know, taking a break. You know, you're procrastinating 46:54 and you're coming, you're playing, you're playing games, you're, you know, placing, you know, bets on, you know, 47:02 s- you know, whether it's the political arena or who's gonna win the NBA finals, um, to just coming on, you know, uh, chatting up your, your frie- your favorite creators, your friends- Mm... 47:14 as well as just, you know, just watching streams. It's having that variety of choice though, isn't it? And I guess that's what keeps people coming back. Um- Yeah. 47:21 And it's kind of turned into this, I, and we keep hammering away at this. You know, I think what Abstract hopefully, uh, becomes is this, uh, you know, kind of this digital Disneyland of fun. 47:33 And that, that's really where we're focused on is- Yeah... is just kind of fun user experiences, at least in these early days. Mm. 47:39 So, so maybe just to kind of round, round out and to maybe put you on the spot a little bit, um, if you were a global IP or a global brand, and perhaps I'll give you two, two alternatives. 47:51 So one, you kind of dabbled in, you know, 2021, 2022, but it didn't become a big part or wherefore it didn't become a big part of your strategy. Yeah. How would you attack it now? 48:02 And then B, if you still haven't dipped your toe, what would be your first move now? I think for those who've been experimenting the last two kind of crypto cycles, um, I'd say good on you, right? 48:14 And these are, these are the folks who were early with, you know, the rise of the commercial internet as well as, you know, uh, you know, you know, kind of building mobile apps. 48:26 And I, you know, I think with them, I think it's, I would say, you know, continue ex- continue to experiment. 48:31 I think this is, you know, uh, you know, when I was at Activision Blizzard, you know, it was mostly, you know, mo- folk- mostly there to launch five games. 48:39 Um, but we were, I was also, you know, kind of keeping tabs on, you know, Web3 and how that intersects with Triple-A gaming. 48:48 And again, like, you know, we didn't do anything, but we were very much, like, ex-exploring- Yeah... different, different use cases for everything from Call of Duty to World of Warcraft to Overwatch. Um, 49:01 and so I, I would say continue to experiment. Um, and I think a lot of this, a lot of this, it's more of a journey than, you know, this like immediate, like, you know, outcome. 49:14 And they're eventually gonna figure something out. Mm-hmm. Um, s- and it's the same people that were early for, you know, to dotcom, to mobile. 49:25 I think for the folks that are just coming into leveraging, uh, crypto rails now, I'd say 49:32 timing is awesome in that the technology has really been, you know, battle tested over the last decade, uh, since Ethereum launched in 2015, to where, you know, you're in a good spot, uh, whereas, like, the tech actually works, right? 49:47 When you're seeing, you know, folks like Oracle Red Bull Racing really just go out there and have great outcomes, um, you know, I wouldn't necessarily FOMO into it, 49:58 but I think tho- things like that are a good signal that, okay, like, the underlying technology is ready. Mm-hmm. Now you just have to figure out, like, what business outcome are you trying to drive to where 50:10 something like Abstract could actually help you. Yeah. Which again, it's not everything... Just like, just like everyone shouldn't have a mobile app- Yeah... right? 50:19 And this, remember, like, like, you know, you go back two computing cycles ago, you know- Or a website. Yeah. Thank you for going back in the day. Everyone had a shoe horn in just to say you were doing something. Yeah. 50:29 That's the wrong strategy, right? Yeah. Like, the, the strategy is like, okay, like how do I, you know, kind of supercharge my existing business? Yeah. 50:37 Or eventually once I've done that, how do I break into new markets, um, you know, using these, you know, emerging technologies? Great. But, um, I, yeah, I would just pace yourself, you know? 50:48 This is- But, but so we're still in a bit of an education phase for, for, for those people, and you're, and you're, you're a great educator. I mean, you can, you can, uh, help them- No, I-... 50:58 as to understand how they can use these things. No, I think, you know, I think the credit always goes to, you know, folks who are, you know, at, at the front edge of all this stuff, right? 51:07 And I think that starts with all the, the startups, right? Like, all the cool kids that are, that are really leveraging unique capabilities of any kind of new computing paradigm. 51:18 And then you always have those, those global brands that are just always on top of things. Um, you know, and I think Red Bull is one of them. 51:27 You know, they'll figure out, okay, by pattern matching, like, what these, like, startups are doing, how they're leveraging blockchain, they're then able to, like, figure out, okay, like, how does this apply to, to some of the business outcomes we're trying to drive? 51:41 And, you know, they'll be pretty quick at it. But again, like, they're probably a good example of, they've been, they've been prototyping for the last two cycles- Mm-hmm... 51:49 to where, you know, it's not a shock or they're, you know, they s- saw something like Abstract and they, you know, leverage the shit out of it to drive great outcomes. And there's others too. 51:59 Um, we're actually working with this one K-pop studio. Um, you know, it'll be their news to, to share hopefully in the, in the coming weeks. But I think the interesting thing there is 52:12 they have an, they have an app where, you know, how do we allow fans to better engage with, you know, that group? And I think there's 24 members of... They have one, they have one group that has 24 members. 52:26 There's two albums a year. One album has all 24 kind of, you know, K-pop idols, and the other one you're voting. It's, it's almost like American Idol- [laughs]... 52:36 back in the day where it's like, you know, which six to eight girls, you know, will be in that second album, to where you can also vote on who goes out on tour, um, who, you know, what's the set list, um, to where now fans are just, you know, feeling like they're really part of, you know, part of that, you know, particular movement. 52:57 Um, and a lot of that is really done through, you know, NFTs and, you know, just having that s- you know, s- that data on the blockchain. And again, it's all hidden. Um, it's abstracted away. 53:11 And, you know, they also now, similar to gaming where, I think this is the other thing, is like, I think video games are probably the one of the few categories within entertainment that you know your entire user base, right? 53:22 Call of Duty, when we're running that, you know, we knew all 250 million players, who the top 1% was, 10%, where the new players, you know, uh, were coming through and, you know, what, what path they wanted to be on. 53:33 Um, you don't necessarily have that, you know, across sports and entertainment, right? [laughs] Whether- But yet all of those businesses are built around fandom. So is it- Preservative. It's huge, yeah. 53:42 And I think this is where this one K-pop studio is, uh, doing something really, really interesting in that you have this kind of mobile app that allows you to interact with, um, you know, the, the studio and the group. 53:54 And again, like, you're, you're able to, you know, start to, like, inventory them, and then now rack and stack them. 54:00 So when you do show up to, you know, they know that their top fan is, you know, a 32-year-old woman in Vancouver. So- [laughs]... 54:09 you know, when you show up to Vancouver as a tour stop, bef- before you even announce it, you know, to get a message, right? 54:17 To message that person and say, "Hey, you know, we're gonna, we're gonna hit, you know, Vancouver on August 15th. We'd love for you to just come backstage, um, and so we can say hello." Hmm. 54:28 Like, you literally created a fan for life. Yeah. Right? There's already that connection there, so it's just enhancing that kind of sense of belonging that they already have. They're rewarding, rewarding it. 54:37 And how, and how technology is enabling us to, to do that. Yeah. It's, it's always enabling, right? It's never the thing that, you know, is running your business. Mm. 54:44 Like, you know, only, you know, core, you know, business strategy and, you know, your actual like, you know, the core product. And in this case, you know, the core product isn't the technology, right? 54:55 It is, you know, it is the 24, you know, K-pop idols that are- Yeah... on stage, uh, and hopefully, you know, creating, you know, creating content that excites a couple of million people. Mm. 55:09 You know, the technology just, you know, it just enhances that experience. Yeah. I think having more understanding gives you more insight into what you need to be doing to engage with that, that audience. 55:20 So I think we'll, we'll have to round it, round it off there. Great stuff, Michael. Michael, thank you so much- Thank you for that... for, for joining us. 55:26 Jay, thanks for being alongside us, and thanks to everyone for, for watching, and we'll see you next time. There it is. [upbeat music]