Transcript 0:00 A lot of the people we talk to can't even get data. Even the sports teams we talk to, you ask them like, "Who are your fans?" And like, "Who's buying tickets?" They don't know. 0:06 Started talking to clubs and were shocked, basically, that category with the most loyal consumer, not just a consumer, but a fan, didn't have a loyalty technology solution that really, you know, targeted them 24/7, 365. 0:22 Sports teams know how to sell attention and eyeballs. It's what they do. You come in the stadium, you look. People watch their games, they look. That's what they monetize. 0:29 Sometimes they say, "We don't even know there's other ways to monetize our product issue," like, "We don't even-- We didn't even know this existed." 0:36 The three years till, you know, everybody knows about this or everybody is participating, and the five to seven when these digital products are actually eclipsing, uh, traditional legacy media products in terms of value. 0:50 Hello, and welcome to The Speakeasy, the podcast of Seg3. 0:54 We're talking to innovators working at the intersection of sports, entertainment, gaming, and technology, the people who are shaping the culture of today and the culture of tomorrow. My name's Jay Stewart. 1:07 I'm very pleased to be here in Los Angeles with my co-host, Jackie Brasky. And joining us is Dominic Carbonaro, who is the Director of Consumer Enterprise at Ava Labs. Thank you for joining us, Dominic. 1:21 Thank you for having me. Excited to be here. Great. 1:24 Let's, let's start with, uh, a bit of an intro into Ava Labs and what it is that you do for people who are not familiar with it, and take us through the basic background of, uh, what the company is about. Okay. 1:38 So we are at Ava Labs, Ava Labs, it's still a debated topic if it's Ava or Ava. Um, we are the entity that represents the Avalanche blockchain. So Avalanche is a Layer 1 blockchain. 1:50 You've probably heard of them, uh, or competitors to them, things like Ethereum, Solana, Sui, Polygon, Avalanche. These are all Layer 1 blockchains. Um, we're unique in our architecture. 2:01 Uh, I like to tell people who are a little confused about like, "Well, what's a Layer 1 blockchain?" Um, [lip smack] there's really three buckets in what I would call like, uh, approaches to scaling from the Layer 1. 2:10 So you have Solana, Sui, which are, uh, Layer 1s that scale at, at the one chain level. So we're gonna put everything into one chain, and that's how we're gonna scale it. Monolithic is the term we use. 2:20 Um, and then you have the Ethereum ecosystem, which is built upon rollups. So there's the base layer Ethereum, and then there's rollups that are built on top of that. They confirm down to the base layer. 2:29 Uh, and then there's Avalanche, which is horizontal scaling. So we have our, our main chain, the primary chain called the C chain, and then we have Layer 1s that are attached to that that use the network. 2:38 Um, so we're more in the horizontal scaling bucket. Uh, I like to say like we really don't know, in my opinion, how blockchains are gonna scale yet. They might scale on one chain. They might scale with rollups. 2:47 They might scale horizontally. Um, but everyone's kind of taken a different approach to try to, uh, address the problem. 2:53 Um, and we've put our, you know, our chips in that basket of we're a horizontal blockchain that, uh, scales Layer 1s. So what's the benefits of horizontal blockchain? 3:00 Well, it's just-- I mean, they all kind of have like their pros and cons. Horizontal blockchains are just-- they're, they're more of a different approach in terms of how, how people prefer to build. 3:09 So we're betting more on that, uh, builders want to own their own stack. They wanna own their chain. They wanna be able to customize their own gas token. 3:18 It's just they're-- I would say they're more builder friendly in my opinion. 3:21 Um, whereas Layer 2s or, uh, things that have like a Layer 2 ecosystem or Solana or, or Sui on the monolithic side, it's really like you gotta do what, what they say. 3:30 Um, you can't have your own custom gas token for your own chain. Um, you're not gonna be able to own your own stack in terms of like who's allowed to deploy assets there. 3:38 So if you're building your own chain, you can say like either you're not-- or you are allowed or you're not allowed, so it's permission versus permissionless. 3:44 So it's more of just the approach for who we-- how we think the market's gonna progress and want to build. 3:49 So s-sorry, but it would seem to me that that horizontal idea is more in line with the, the thesis of what blockchain ultimately should be about, which is about ownership, correct? I, I would say so. 4:01 I mean, our, our founder's been doing this for a v- a very long time, so like I think he took very much of a builder's first approach in saying that like people who build their own chain are going to want to have total control, whether that's for like regulatory reasons. 4:14 So maybe you wanna deploy a, a chain that allows certain types of KYC'd funds, and you wanna make sure the only people that can interact with those funds are, are people who are KYC'd to comply with, um, you know, certain types of anti-money laundering things that the government puts out or w-whatever variety of regulation that, you know, the government's gonna put out. 4:32 Um, we started very much with a finance focus, uh, so that was around like, yeah, if, if a bank wants to deploy its own chain, how can they do that way that's regulatory friendly? 4:40 Um, so yeah, it's, it's, uh, it's much more own your own stack approach, I would say, than 4:48 you gotta deploy here and your assets when they're deployed like on like a Solana or a Sui, you're deployed with everyone else's assets. 4:54 So if some random person creates some random thing, your assets are on that chain for better or for worse. 5:00 Um, so there are some like I would say branding risks or just like some hesitancy from people who are like, "I don't know if I wanna put my bank's assets on a chain with a certain type of meme coin." 5:11 Like, I don't even know if I want that there, right? So, um, it's just really approach, a builder approach, I would say. Now, what about Ava Labs or Ava Labs? 5:18 Where do, where, yeah, where do you fit into that, uh, picture? So we are the entity that represents the chain. So, uh, the Avalanche blockchain has a foundation, uh, and then we are a contractor of that foundation. 5:29 So we have products that we launch within the ecosystem, so we have a wallet, core wallet. We have Ava Cloud, which is, uh, you can think of it, um, like a managed service provider for L1. 5:37 So just like how in Amazon you can one-click deploy, um, you know, an instance and, and Amazon will manage the infrastructure, if you wanna one-click deploy a Layer 1 blockchain, Ava Labs will do that for you and manage it. 5:48 So that's another product we have. We have the business development team that I sit on, so that's, you know, pushing partnerships for the chain, getting people to work with us. 5:56 Um, and then we have obviously like legal, finance, and, and the actual team that builds the underlying infrastructure and tech for the blockchain. So when you say consumer, the, the, um Uh, consumer enterprise. 6:07 Where does-- why is it called consumer? Yeah. 6:10 So the consumer enterprise vertical, um, you can think of it as any time an enterprise is building applications that touch con- like large-scale consumer use cases that are not financialized, that's what my vertical owns. 6:25 Um, so like a good example of this would be, um, if you've ever seen the show Love Island, you know how Love Island has the voting app where you download the app, you can vote for your characters? 6:35 That would be like a consumer app, not like a financialized neobank Robinhood-style app, right? So myself and Jake sit on that, uh, that side of the stack. Nice. 6:45 So it's partnerships essentially, but more so, yeah, non-financial based. Yeah, non-fi-- yeah, non- non-financialized. 6:50 We have a whole 'nother team that does, um, like crypto-native financial stuff as well as like institutional, uh, banking-type stuff. And then what kind of companies are you guys working with? Yeah, it's a good question. 7:01 So, um, it might make sense to talk about our strategy and how we got to, like, selecting our partners for this. Um, 7:11 so I think what we noticed early on was blockchain and crypto, whatever web3, whatever word you wanna use now, um, was building a lot of nice to haves or like, "That's cool," I would say. 7:23 Um, like, we're gonna build this NFT app that lets you memorialize your time at the event, and we'll give you a token that shows that, and it's really cool. 7:31 Well, like, that, that's cool doesn't really drive business decision makers to actually adopt things, right? We were looking for businesses that did one of three things. 7:41 Either they created new revenue streams without cannibalizing existing ones, reduced bottom lines or made things more efficient, so processes that would take, you know, sixty, ninety days now down to one or two days. 7:51 Or three, generated new revenue streams that they could use for, uh, decision-making processes or informing LLMs. We're seeing more of a, a push towards that. Unique data is the differentiator for LLMs. 8:02 Um, and so with that, we started going out and saying, "Okay, what are applications that are building in the general crypto space that are addressing these things?" 8:09 Um, and they have to make sure that blockchain is an integral part of that, right? So it can't be like, well, we could do that, but, like, we're just adding in blockchain, um, just for like, just to have it. 8:17 It has to be like, it's not possible to generate new revenue without block- without blockchain. And so the verticals we, we found for that were, um, identity-based products, so things like, um, 8:28 being able to understand who your fans are, where they are, what they do, um, uh, things like ticketing and on-chain loyalty. 8:34 So those were the kind of the three big verticals we saw demand for early on in sports that were actual needle movers for, for decision makers within sports organizations. 8:43 So basically when it comes to the discussions that you have, um, y-you go with the perspective of obviously as a blockchain company. But I understand that 8:56 ultimately now people don't really care whether it's blockchain or Web3 or whatever it is. It's, it's what it does. Yeah. Because the consumer, the end user is not gonna know, and 9:05 it-it's just a question of whether it's the efficiency or whether it's able to do the things that you were talking about. So what do those conversations look like? So from, I would say, 9:16 blah, there probably is two approaches. So one with, let's say for the organizations, right? Uh, you're right. 9:21 A lot of them do not, I would say, want the user to have to go through this really extenuous process of like, you need to create a wallet, and then once your wallet's created, you gotta save the eighteen words so no one ever figures it out. 9:32 And if you lose those words, you lose your money. Like, this is way too much friction. Uh, you know, people are used to clicking a button and then logging in with their Google ID, and that's it. 9:41 And that's, that's the user flow. That's not gonna change. So, um, the term for that in our space is called account abstraction. So how do you abstract away the blockchain so it just feels like a Web2 app, right? 9:51 That's always kinda top and center for any organization we talk to. 9:55 They want it to just feel like a traditional app, but they want the benefits of the blockchain for their organization and for their users without the users necessarily having to go through this, all these loops and processes. 10:03 Can, can I ask a question before you go on? Is this something that's happened th-with, with technological development, or was that possibility always there, that account abs- uh, abstraction thing? 10:15 Oh, this has been like, a lot of resources have been poured into this at the application layer a-as well as the networking layer to make account abstraction possible. 10:24 Um, you know, a company like, a company like Privy who does, uh, account abstracted wallets so it just feels like a login, they just sold to Stripe, I think, for like a billion dollars. 10:33 So it's been a huge push for people to build these things out, and then as they've shown their worth, they're now starting to even get acquired and rolled up to other businesses. 10:41 Um, so yeah, it's, it was a huge push from developers to get this kind of feeling for, for users. So you were saying the, the account abstraction was one thing that the, these companies wanted- Yeah... uh, automatically. 10:52 And then what else were they were looking for? They wanted the benefits of the, of bl- of, uh, of blockchain. Did they understand the benefits or do they understand the benefits? Yeah, that's a good question. 11:02 I think it comes down to, like, what are some of the, the, the, or like, what are some of the barriers or hurdles to, to winning business? Um, I'd say education is a huge one. You know, most people when they hear 11:12 crypto, they think Bitcoin. It's like the first thing they think about. Uh, and then if they're past that or they've worked with it, then they think, like, FTX or Luna. So- Yeah... 11:22 there's some definite scarring, and especially- Or Memecoin. Or Memecoin, yeah, especially in sports. 11:26 So I think there is not as much education in terms of, uh, how do these things benefit your business or how do these things benefit users. There is a lot that goes into that and having to explain those benefits. Um, 11:39 but it is a, a, you know, it is a fruitful conversation, and sometimes you even have to start with, "Hey, we're just gonna do this one really small thing." Like, "I know where I'm gonna take you in three or four years." 11:49 Uh, like, "It might not be ready for that, but we're gonna start just, just this one simple thing, and we'll add onto it and eventually get there." 11:56 When you're talking to these companies, what do you find that, you know, once you kind of walk them off the ledge of fear, what sort of resonates with them on, you know, being like, "Okay, this does make sense"? Yeah. 12:06 So I think a good example, and most people get, is this concept of, like, loaded value. Um- So if we think about, like, Starbucks app. Do you use the Starbucks app? I don't like Starbucks. 12:19 [laughs] But yes, I'm familiar with that. You're familiar with the app? Yeah. Taste, coffee tastes burnt. You, you pre- [laughs] You preload value into the Starbucks app. You spend, you generate stars, right? 12:30 That preloaded value is a huge business line item for Starbucks, right? It's, like, two billion-plus dollars they have just sitting in that app. They generate yield from it. 12:39 There's teams dedicated towards building this out. 12:42 Um, you know, for sports teams, I think you can take the approach of a, of a prelo- pre- preloaded value approach, but instead of using dollars, you can use stable coins, which are a much more efficient form of money. 12:53 So things where you need 100-plus teams to manage it can actually just make that preloaded value a stable coin, which then generates yields for the business. 13:00 Um, and then you can also capture, uh, like, actual fan loyalty, which I think is really underexposed in sports. 13:06 So just like people load their Starbucks app or use their Fly Mile Delta, Delta cards, they can use those styles of apps for sports teams, um, and then, you know, redeem the points for in-stadium experiences, merchandise, whatever it may be. 13:19 But it's the same type of preloaded value loyalty process that already exists for businesses, but we're just applying that to sports teams. But so then why blockchain? 13:26 By the way, I spent many years working with music and Web3, so these are all... 13:30 You know, uh, I've, I've been through the struggle of all these questions and, and the ups and downs of the industry, but, you know, that was always my problem is, like, when it was hot, everyone wanted to do it, and then once you got past that, it was like, "Well, why do I need blockchain for this?" 13:43 Or we would always have to hide it behind the scenes. Yeah. 13:46 So I would say, one, uh, if you're going to take on the, like, the preloaded loyalty approach, which we'll have John come and talk about here in a few, um, stable coins are just a better form of money than cash. Mm-hmm. 13:58 So it's just more efficient for a business to use them. Uh, that's the first thing. The second thing, which you can get to- Can you say, can you explain why? Why- Without getting too monopoly. 14:06 Yeah, why is it more efficient? Okay. So one, if you're any type of entity... 14:10 Like, we'll just take a step back, and let's just speak on, like, why would a, why would a business use stable coins over cash in general, okay? Let's say you're a company like FedEx, okay? 14:21 FedEx has to have several different entities set up in different parts of the co- parts of the world, right? They might have a South Korean entity. They might have an Indian entity. 14:30 They, they have a, a, an English entity, and they do that specifically because if, let's say, the US comes in and sanctions a country one day, they just close that entity, right? 14:40 And that they don't have to deal with shutting down the entire business. With that, money has to move cross borders. It's extremely painful, and it costs a lot of money. 14:47 Stable coins allow for very, very fluid cross-border payments, so that's, like, just one example of why, um, you know, stable coins are just a better form of money for, for, for, for enterprises. 14:58 The second one being, um, certain types of stable coins if you wanna do a pre- pre-value loaded program, right? The big, the big benefit of that is a lot of these companies take those dollars, and they manage them. 15:09 They put them in, um, you know, certain types of, uh, short, short-term, uh, interest accounts, buying short-term bonds, whatever it may be. That's a, that's a process. It's hard for a business to do. 15:19 You have to have a team for that. I believe Starbucks's team is, like, 100 or 150 people that just manages the finance side. 15:25 There's stable coins that exist that will automate that for you, and they p- they pass back the yield. 15:28 You know, the, the, the stable coin business takes a piece of it, but if they're saying, "Hey, we're making 4.5% on your deposits, we're gonna keep a percent. 15:35 You're gonna get 3.5%, and now you don't have to hire any of a team to manage it," it's an easy way for you to start to generate yield on preloaded accounts as opposed to having to scale up an entire team to do it. 15:45 So, um, yeah, cross- cross-border remittances, e- ease of use to spin up, um, you know, yield-bearing accounts. 15:53 There's a f- you know, there's a few others, um, but I'd say those are probably the two primary ones that are pretty easy for people to understand. What about the idea of, um, owning data? 16:04 I mean, isn't this one of the, one of the, the, the main, um, selling points of Web3 and a blockchain is the idea that you-- that, that data does not go on a platform that's a third party that's controlled by someone else or one of the big platforms. 16:21 You have control over it yourself. Is this relevant to the, um, the rights owners or to the people that you're talking to? Um, I would say a lot of the people we talk to can't even get data. 16:33 [chuckles] So, like, like, a lot of the s- like, even the sports teams we talk to, you ask them, like, "Who are your fans?" And like, "Who's buying tickets?" They don't know. They don't know. Ticketmaster owns that data. 16:41 Yep. Right. Exactly. Again, the same in, in music, we have that same problem. Exactly. Like, who are your fans, and what are they buying? Exactly. And where do they live? Exactly. And who, like, who are they? 16:48 So I would say the, the first problem is can they even get data on their users? The question to that's usually no. So, um, the concept of a wallet, right, inside of an app, that's a, that's a person, right? 17:00 And so you can start to see who that person is. If you have programs where you link cards, you can actually start to see where do they shop. Do they shop at partners you work with, right? 17:08 Um, and so once you have those apps, you can... 17:12 When that, when that data is on chain, there's opportunities for you to let people come in and use that data, and it's not, it's not as hard to share 'cause they can just access it via the chain as long as you create the permissions for it. 17:23 Um, that's called interoperability, right? So it's a big concept we have. Uh, so the data's not as walled gardened, but if you want to, you can open it up, um, which I think lends really well to loyalty, right? 17:34 So if you're like, you're really great friends with the New York Mets, and in return a local business wants to tap into that, you can very easily access that. 17:42 So basically for teams, for example, as, as sports franchises, for example, this is a way for them kind of to, to even begin their data journey and to, to start to know who their fans are and know who is at the game. 17:57 Classic thing being you have 20,000 people in an arena, you don't e- you don't even know anything. You don't even know who's there. Yeah. 18:03 And you can also start to see what they do outside of your fan experience, which is important to them. Well, that's a very good time for us to, to bring in our next guest. 18:12 Thank you for joining us, and, uh, you're joining us from Miami. I believe you, you guys actually w- got to see the MLS Cup final, which must have been fun. Really fun. Yeah. Part of the joy of working in sports. 18:22 That's right. So tell us about, uh, UpTop and, and, um, and how it fits in with what we've been hearing about before. 18:29 It's, uh, how blockchain is, is, uh, changing what sports can do and building their loyalty possibilities. Yeah, of course. It-- First of all, thanks for having me. 18:39 It's really good to be here for the conference, and we're excited for all the wonderful programming ahead. Um, I think Dominic broke down the sort of division of responsibilities pretty well. 18:50 They're an infrastructure provider, and we're an app. We're, we're a company that, you know, builds a product that then interfaces with end consumers. Um, so, 19:01 uh, I started this company after leaving PayPal, where we would analyze millions of data points on every single consumer and really try and engage them, um, and retarget them and understand the inflection points of a consumer journey, uh, from a data perspective. 19:18 Um, and so we launched a bunch of different products there. 19:22 Uh, consumer B, uh, P2P payments, uh, crypto support in the PayPal and Venmo apps, and ultimately, uh, the PYUSD stable coin, which came out after I left the company, uh, was kind of the beginnings of a consumer company getting into this space, um, with, with such a degree of scale. 19:41 Um, and I had the thesis that a lot of brands would benefit from this kind of technology. 19:47 Um, so we set out, uh, at UpTop to build essentially what's-- what we call a wallet in a box, a solution that we can give to any, uh, consume, uh, consumer company that has the benefits of all of these fintech products, that has the benefits of, call it a Starbucks loyalty app, without incurring, uh, the operational complexities, the financial complexities, the multi-jurisdictional c-complexities that Dom spoke about, and can just be programmed and, and, um, and customized for their exact use case. 20:22 Um, we have worked across verticals, but, uh, as of late, our, our, our m- our biggest vertical with the most traction is, is professional sports. Um, 20:35 this was actually a category, uh, that had been neglected by technology providers, uh, for a very long time. 20:43 Um, teams didn't necessarily have the resources internally to build full-fledged loyalty programs that have all of these consumer financial primitives embedded in the solution. 20:54 Um, so we started pitching this idea in the professional sports vertical. 20:59 Um, we had recently hired, uh, someone from a sports partnership background, um, who had launched a lot of, uh, NFT and token-based activations with different professional teams. 21:11 And, uh, we started talking to clubs and were shocked basically that, um, a category with the most loyal consumer, not just a consumer, but a fan, didn't have, um, a loyalty technology solution that really, you know, targeted them twenty-four seven, three sixty-five, uh, as they went about their life. 21:35 Um, and at that time, the Cleveland Cavaliers and the NBA were actually RFPing this category. They were talking to all of the vendors in the space, um, and we didn't even have a product in market. 21:46 Um, but they went with us because of the sort of forward-thinking strategy that we had, uh, been presenting and talking about in our initial pitches. 21:55 Um, so that was at the start of last NBA season, so we're in our second season with them and, and have added a few clubs this year. Nice. 22:04 Um, you know, I've-- I always say working in music and when I have, you know, friends or colleagues who work in sports, we're always jealous of each other because of the different, you know, complexities of rights holders that we have. 22:14 Have you found that the teams, do they need the NBA's approval? Like, what is the process of onboarding these different teams, and do you need the league approval, and is it sport by sport basis? 22:23 You know, what's sort of the, the onboarding process been like? Yeah, it can be- You're laughing. [chuckles] It can be league dependent. Uh, in the case of the NBA, um, uh, the, the league does sign off in most cases. 22:34 Um, so we're now, uh, live with both the Pistons and the Cleveland Cavaliers. Um- Are the Lakers next? No, I'm joking. [chuckles] We, we, we, uh- [chuckles] We're growing. Let's just say we're growing. 22:47 Um- I mentioned them before. I'm born and raised LA, so I love my Lakers and Dodgers. Um, I mean, they've done such amazing things, both, both teams actually from a consumer kind of product standpoint. 22:58 Um, obviously very exciting IPs for anyone in this space. Um, and we're, we're gonna be growing our footprint in the league. Um, but the question, remind me the, the actual question. 23:09 Say, is it, I mean, each sport, is it really hard? I mean, I-- we all know basketball and NBA. Yeah. They've always been, I'd say they're pretty innovative, obviously, with NBA Pop Shop. Right. It's about their rights. 23:16 Yeah. Yeah. So- Um, so have you found that, you know, you've been leaning basketball or what other sports? You know, how has sort of the process been with the leagues and teams? 23:24 Yeah, we have a foothold in, in the NBA for sure. Um, this is a rights-based market, right? So, um, in some cases, we're licensing IP. It depends on the exact, uh, implementation that, uh, the team wants to go with. 23:39 Um, in other cases, you know, we've had some conversations in leagues where everything is centrally managed by, by the league. Um, they, you know, participate in every single consumer use case. 23:52 Um, and then we've had some conversations internationally, uh, where the franchise model isn't as present in, in sports, and we're directly just interfacing with the club, and, and, and they are the ultimate rights holder. 24:04 Um, in some cases, they're also working with third-party agencies managing these relationships. Uh, so it really varies. 24:11 Um, we just have to make sure that we have the people internally, uh, and the expertise to handle these kind of complex, uh, rights deals. So let, let me take a step back. 24:22 So you were saying you're, there's an IP, and you're, you're licensing the, the, the IP. In some cases, yeah In some cases. 24:29 Yeah Because you c-- you know how to basically do what it is that needs to be done because the teams don't normally have the internal team to do that. Is that- Yeah. So it-... mainly what it is? It, it runs the gamut. 24:41 Um, like right now, um, we're in the NBA with the Cavs and the Pistons. We're, uh, uh, launching LSU in a question of a couple weeks here across all sports. Um, and so 24:56 some teams, um, they do have an internal function just focused on loyalty or product, and they're just using our technology stack. Uh, others, um, 25:06 don't really know where to begin, uh, so our, our approach with them is, um, more a traditional rights deal. It's, it's remarkable how, l- I'm gonna use the word backward, 25:19 how, how, um, behind sports is in, in, in this world, m- maybe because they have not, um, had a chance to develop the internal resources, and they haven't had the bandwidth internally to be able to focus on innovation because they've been too busy just doing what it is that they do. 25:36 So have you found that this is generally true across sports and that you have these... Is it kind of an open door that you're pushing against? 25:44 Yeah, look, I mean, there's some really innovative products that have come out. You mentioned Top Shot in its moment when, you know, collector mania was, was really reflected in the digital asset space. 25:55 Um, you could really in- innovate across this, um, high speed, high consumer velocity, uh, product cycle. Um, and in sports generally, um, I think resourcing is the biggest constraint. 26:09 So it usually does take a third party, um, who can really understand the business and can work closely with the stakeholders in partnership, um, to, to push, you know, the, uh, the boundaries of what's possible. 26:22 Uh, the teams, at the end of the day, they have to spend most of their time and focus on their core product, which is fielding a great, uh, ex- a, a great viewer experience and fielding a great team that people wanna watch. 26:34 The product is ultimately the sports team. Um, so you see-- that's why you see major investment in player contracts and trading for, for athletes and, and getting the right coaches involved. 26:47 Um, and a lot of other things are third-party managed. You know, it's rare, but it exists, I believe, in LA in some cases. 26:54 In s- in some of the teams, they do do it, but most teams don't even handle their own concessions, right? That's usually- Right, right... operated by a Levy or an Aramark. Um, so this is similar. 27:05 Um, and so we consider s- ourselves a fintech company and a, and, and a, a media participant as well. 27:11 So, so from a consumer, a fan's point of view, um, and we can join it up with the team and the fan, what is the experience? What is it that they get, um, as a user of the app? 27:26 Yeah, Dom, I believe you wanted to chime in with something. I was gonna add something on the previous point. Okay. Uh, you mentioned resourcing. 27:35 A good example is if you've ever seen Yankee Stadium, there's a sign in right field that says WB Mason. It's on the wall. WB Mason sponsors it. 27:41 That sign's been there since my dad's been a kid, when he was going to games in the '60s. Sports teams know how to sell attention and eyeballs. That's what they do. You come in the stadium, you look. 27:49 People watch their games, they look. That's what they monetize. Airlines did this, too. They knew how to sell flights, right? I think Delta did two billion dollars last quarter to American Express in points. 27:59 That didn't exist 15, 20, 30 years ago, or whenever they started that. But those, those industries eventually evolve, and they just stop doing-- let's just stop selling the core product. 28:09 I think sports are at an inflection point with that. You can only sell eyeballs and attention so much. You have to look at other ways in which you wanna drive your business, drive your business forward. 28:18 So it's like when you, when you-- when we talked about, like, is it a staffing issue? 28:21 Sometimes it's a, we don't even know there's other ways to monetize our product issue, that c- we don't even-- we didn't even know this existed. 28:29 Um, and when you talked about the, the, the core product experience, um, for me, when I've used it, I-- okay, I'll bring, go b- go back to this Love Island point 'cause I always-- I harp on it 'cause I watch my wife force me to download that app. 28:45 And vote. And I thought to myself, "What's something I would actually download and use as a, as a male consumer? 28:51 What's an app I'm gonna d- I'm not gonna ever vote on Love Island, but, like, what's something I would actually download and use?" 28:55 The concept of, like, a sports app where I could participate interactively, get points for spending or doing things, redeem those for experiences. Like, that's something I would actually do as a consumer of a team. 29:06 Um, and so I think that, you know, it's his thesis, too. That market is hugely untapped 'cause, you know, s- fans spend. I buy a Jets jersey every year, even though the player's not gonna be on the team next year. 29:18 Yeah, it's the case. I've bought four jerseys, and they all keep leaving, but I'm loyal to the team, and I'll keep consuming. Uh, unfortunately, I've got the curse of a Jets fan, but, um- Yeah, that's-... 29:27 if you wanna go to the app... that's a great segue into the product, right? And, and, and what we're unlocking. 29:32 Um, but yeah, the, the airline example is, is pretty much table stakes in the industry now, but it was developed over time to monetize a new revenue stream, which is essentially the issuance of miles. 29:44 Uh, so in the case of the professional teams we're working with, um, we're essentially issuing points. 29:51 Um, and so we can financialize, uh, the loyalty program of the team and make it a revenue-generating asset, and we do that by selling points, uh, to third-party sponsors of the team. It's basically a new Ray card asset. 30:06 That's all it is. Uh, they buy those points to market to the consumer, and they do that by distributing them in a transaction-based rewards program- That's a great point... from a wallet. 30:15 So you can get your points at the supermarket and your credit card points. Yeah, yeah. You, you can double-dip. So it's like, why wouldn't... Yeah. Why wouldn't you do it, right? Exactly. 30:22 And it's the same reason you wouldn't forget to put your, um, you know, your airline, uh, identifier number when you buy a Delta Ticket, right? 30:32 Um, and that's the start of the journey, and then inside of that, of course, so this is a revenue-generating asset. It's growing season over season. 30:39 Um, I believe fundamentally that it, you know, these attribution-based digital-first assets are, uh, going to eventually eclipse, um, impression media assets, right? 30:51 Because you can actually see that the consumer went to that business. Uh, and you alluded to this before, folks are asking for attribution, right? Um, you know, everybody knows that sports marketing works. 31:05 Um, there's always a question of, you know, which parts work really well and which parts, um, you know, may just be brand affiliation-based. 31:14 Um, our asset is all around, you know, active participation and real attribution. So we're getting sponsors these, um, these conversion-based assets that they can now purchase. Um, so that's kind of the baseline. 31:27 Once you're in a points-based system, there's a lot of really great features you can, you know, add, right? That keep attention, that keep eyeballs on the product. 31:36 Um, and so we're doing things like points rewards for predictions. Uh, you could predict, you know, the over-under of the next game, um, or the spread, right? 31:48 So it's, it's, you know, keeping you engaged in a non-cash wager, uh, uh, format that is, um, giving you some skin in the game, some participation without, you know, financial damage, only upside. 32:02 Um, so those are the kinds of- And we live in California. We don't have gambling, sports gambling here. Correct. So, uh, we could probably do it for the Lakers one day. Um, [chuckles] so yeah. 32:13 So, so for the consumer, for the fan- Uh-huh... um, they build up points, correct? Correct. So they get points- Yeah... and then they can use those points- In-... to anticipate. 32:23 Yeah, in the, in the ecosystem of the team, right? So this is, uh, things like merchandise, ticketing, uh, experiences, money-can't-buy things, meet and greets with the players. 32:34 We've distributed courtside seats twice per team in a season. 32:39 Uh, we've done fully expenses paid away game trips for top participants as well, and we can afford to do that through the program and still have a profitable unit economic model, um, because of sponsor particip-participation. 32:56 Um, so what you see with rewards programs often is, like, you know, people make a splash in year one, like, "Look at all these great things that you can get," but then if they're not actually monetizing the program and creating revenue streams, uh, year two is all about scaling back and how do we reduce the amount of, uh, rewards that we can distribute through this program. 33:16 We actually grow year over year, right? We have more users, and then we have more sponsors, so we can actually just-- Our network coverage gets bigger, and we can, um, you know, 33:27 build some really, really exciting, um, hooks, uh, on the reward redemption side for the fans. Now on the data, jumping to the data issue- Yeah... just so it's clear. So that data, that fan data, is, 33:39 i-is the club's data, that they can- Correct... th-that they can archive, they can hold, they can- Yeah... continue to, to use. That's right, yeah. And, um, you did ask a, like, a why Web3 question to Dom before. 33:52 And so we, we have a, you know, an IP rights holder first strategy. All that data is theirs. 34:00 But with our infrastructure, the fan graph, the actual nodes, the people that are participating that they may wanna reach, uh, long after we're ever in partnership with a team, if we left, they could still access the, the consumer wallet and continue their program without a hitch, and that is actually fundamentally something you could only really do with, um, on chain ledgering infrastructure. 34:23 And the stablecoin option. You know, the, the- For payments, yes. Yeah. 34:27 Yeah, so, um, actually, next year we'll be introducing our first stablecoin supporting programs, um, and powering, um, payments experiences for fans as well. 34:37 The costs, you know, you mentioned all the complexities of offeri-offering a loaded value wallet. The cost is also there as well. So it's really interesting. If you look at, um, sort of 34:50 loyalty programs today and just kind of, uh, you know, targeting and retargeting of consumers generally, the most loyal consumer often becomes the most expensive consumer if there's a high-transaction, low-dollar, uh, payment type that occurs often, which can be the case in, you know, any, you know, any concession purchase or you buy a coffee or you buy whatever. 35:14 Um, you're getting hit over and over with, um, payment fees from, you know, all up and down the traditional payment stack, card networks, banks, et cetera. 35:24 So getting people into a loaded value environment leveraging stablecoins, you-- and, and a technology like Avalanche, you're down to fractions of a penny for, for, um, for those kinds of transactions. 35:38 Um, so you hear this kind of constantly, you know, coffee shops spend more on credit card fees than they do on, um, coffee beans. That's just a fact. It's, it's tragic in a sense. Um, 35:51 Starbucks is actually better at reducing those co-costs than the coffee shop on the corner because they have the capability to do this, right? 36:00 So we wanted to sort of democratize access to these, um, complex loaded value wallets, make it simple for the, for the rights holder, make it simple for the consumer, and under the hood, we're, we're taking care of the, the heavy lift. 36:13 Oh, this sounds like an, if I'm a fan of a team, it sounds like an absolute no-brainer to join. 36:17 How's been the onboarding process, you know, for these teams to communicate to fans, getting them to join, the learning curve? You know, how has that process been? 36:25 Yeah, it's, it's pretty straightforward, to be honest, right? They're in the business already of, of marketing, right? 36:30 And what they get with our asset is An asset that they can market and own and benefit from year over year. So you rely on the sport, the teams are marketing that. Yeah, they- They're just, you're providing the service. 36:40 Yeah... they're marketing machines. They're, they're great at that. Um, that's their strength. 36:43 They can grow their own loyalty program on the jumbotron or, or in, in a push notification to their mobile app or, uh, through a ticketing promotion email. 36:52 We've done, we've done things like gate pre-s- ticket pre-sale access to our, um, most loyal fans in the program. So their, their fans are getting pre-sale access. 37:03 We get, you know, thousands of signups when that happens. Um, and this asset then, again, just becomes more valuable over the years. Let me ask a question about, about, um, your po- your potential market. 37:14 You've got some tier one, you know, you've got NBA teams. I mean, that's top of the, top of the, the, uh, pile there. 37:22 In terms of costs and in terms of, uh, accessibility, what are the possibilities for sports entities that are farther down the, uh, the pyramid to be able to use this kind of technology? 37:34 Because they're often the ones that are, that are most in need. 37:37 I'm thinking of international federations or national federations or, um, organizations that have lots and lots of members, but they're not monetizing them at all really, apart from taking maybe membership fees. 37:51 Yeah, that's a really, really great question. Often the grassroots in, in sports is, you know, managed by a federation and not by a, a professional league. We have these discussions internally all the time. 38:03 We've met some of these, uh, federations across various sports. We've met minor league teams and leagues. Um, and sort of my message to them is, is, um, we want every fan that you onboard to be 38:20 a net benefit to you and for you to just be able to grow with the program. Um, so whether you have millions of members or, or, or 5,000, it, it should not matter. 38:31 Uh, this asset should be valuable to you with every interaction, with all of the data that you generate. 38:37 Uh, so we do everything from, you know, pricing to, to the way we build this stat-- te- tech stack to accommodate that, that philosophy. Every new user is just adding value to a network. Um, and yeah, I mean, they, 38:53 you know, they could, uh, benefit from the same tech as, as some of these, these, uh, marquee rights holders that we work with today. So in terms of the, the trajectory of, of growth, you said it's a no-brainer. Mm. 39:07 I think it's a no-brainer too. [chuckles] I mean, how long do you think it's gonna be before there's general adoption across sports of, of this kind of technology? Because it would seem to be something that's, uh- Uh... 39:20 extremely needed. Yeah. Whose answer is UR Mine or his, um, so I tend to be, like, more bullish, but I think it's probably not realistic 'cause, like, 39:29 I think you'll see, like, pretty widespread adoption in, like, three years, and by, like, five to seven years it'll be standard that you will be monetizing a points program inside of your network, just like Delta. 39:40 It'll be a new line item of, of revenue within- Yeah... five to seven years. I think that's a great answer. I mean, we're, we're looking at national rights holders already. 39:48 We're looking at it at major international, uh, events, um, you know, the ones you would, you would know about, um, who are, are all interested in this category. 39:59 Um, so-- And then once you have enlisted users, they can use the same wallets. There's repeatability across programs in theory. Um, these are all primitives that we wanna enable. 40:11 And so, um, yeah, I think your timeline is accurate. 40:14 I think it's probably the three years till, you know, everybody knows about this or everybody is participating and the, and the five to seven, uh, when these digital products are actually eclipsing, uh, traditional legacy media products in terms of value. 40:29 Uh, and that's my, like, very aggressive, perhaps hot take, but, uh, I think it's totally possible. Great. Great. Well, we'll, we'll end there. Um, thanks very much Dominic and John for joining us. 40:41 Really interesting, and, uh, good luck with this because I think you've got a product that everyone is going to be, uh, getting, uh, pretty soon. Uh, thank you for joining us on The Speakeasy. 40:54 Thank you for watching The Speakeasy, and be sure that you keep watching The Speakeasy. Bye for now. [upbeat music]